unnecessary imported non-essential goods

As salaamu alaikum
Dear hazrat;
We would like to hear your comments on the following:
Omar Javaid:
میں نے ایک مفتی صاحب سے کچھ دن پہلے ایک سوال پوچھا:
اسلام علیکم، پوچھنا یہ تھا کے جو ملک اشیاء import کرنے کے لیے IMF سے سود پر قرضہ لیتا ہو کیا اس ملک کے
شہری کا غیر ضروری imported non-essential اشیاء کا خریدنا اور افراطِ زر کو بڑھانے میں حصہ دار بنا جائز ہے
کہ نہیں؟
جواب: جائز ہے اگرچہ مناسب نہیں۔۔ الا یہ کہ حکومت امپورٹ پر پابندی عائد کردے ۔۔۔ پھر اولی الامر کی خلاف ورزی
کی وجہ سے ناجائز ہوگا

I asked a Mufti Sahib a question a few days ago:
Peace be upon you, I just wanted to ask that a country that takes loans from IMF on interest to import goods, is it permissible for a citizen of that country to buy unnecessary imported non-essential goods and participate in increasing the excess of gold?
Answer: It is permissible though not appropriate.. Except that the government imposes a ban on imports.. Then it will be illegal because of Oli-Umar’s violation..

Ali Raza Saleem
The boundary between essential and non essential is subjective..

Omar Javaid
Ali Raza Saleem there is perhaps a gray zone, but it is not broad enough to cover everything, there is clearly a list of stuff I believe where there can’t be any debate … If you ask me, we should not be even importing tea ….

Umãir Sãni
If its possible for a follow up:

  1. The verse in which the command to obey the First Command of Allah and His Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) is the command to obey Allah and His Messenger, before that, was it not obedience to the creatures in disobedience of the Creator?
  2. The attributes of Oli-Amar include the ability to “discipline” according to the Quran, do the current rulers live up to this definition?

Mudassir Ijaz Paracha
I asked a question about real estate, and the answer was exactly the same. Not every legitimate job with this increase.

Was salaam
Hassaan sulaiman

ASSALAMU ALAIKUM
13 Zul Qa’dh 1443 – 14 June 2022

Hassan Sulaiman

The government of Pakistan is kuffaar. Every government in Pakistan
since its inception, has abolished the Shariah. Disobeying the laws
of this kuffaar, murtad government is NEVER sinful.

Was-salaam

A.S.Desai

Mujlisul Ulama of S.A.